Melatonin vs. Benadryl for sleep: Which is more effective?

Are you the sort that falls asleep but then wakes up every so often throughout the night? Perhaps your sleep is restless. Maybe you sleep for a total of eight hours but wake up exhausted. It happens to millions of people every night, so you’re not alone if any of the previous descriptions match your experiences.

The problem is that there could be a host of reasons why your sleep is suffering. Moreover, you must find a solution to your sleep issues because a lack of sleep is behind many other health problems. While a person’s lifestyle might lie at the root of sleep troubles, most want an immediate fix.

With that in mind, many individuals turn to over-the-counter remedies like melatonin or Benadryl. There are benefits and downsides to both, so we put together this brief comparison that we hope will help you choose what’s best for you.

Man in Green Shirt Lying on Bed
Photo by SHVETS productions/Pexels

Benadryl vs. melatonin: which one is right for you?

First of all, take note of the symptoms you’re experiencing. Suppose they seem to be more extensive than what a simple over-the-counter medication can solve. In that case, it’s best to see a medical professional.

With that said, Benadryl (diphenhydramine) lessens the effects of histamines in the body. In other words, it’s an antihistamine that’s often used to alleviate allergy symptoms like itching, watery eyes, sneezing, and a runny nose. However, it can also be used to treat some Parkinson’s disease symptoms, motion sickness, and it can induce sleep.

Melatonin is a natural hormone on the other hand. Your body produces it to help maintain your overall wake-sleep cycle. It can be made synthetically, and you can find it sold as a dietary supplement in the United States.

Typically, melatonin is used to help adjust the sleep cycles of blind people, reduce the symptoms of jet lag, and treat sleep disorders in people who have alternating day/night work schedules. However, it’s also used for general insomnia.

Both Benadryl and melatonin can help you if you’re trying to get to sleep. Here are the benefits of each.

The benefits of Melatonin

As previously noted, melatonin is a chemical that your body produces naturally. In fact, it’s one of your body’s principal sleep-inducing hormones. It typically activates when it starts to get dark outside, and it stops being active when the sun rises.

Because modern life presents all kinds of challenges to people who desperately need sleep, scientists worked to synthesize melatonin. They knew that things like the screens of your digital devices throw off blue light, which interferes with your brain’s parts that make you feel alert. Plus, it’s been well-documented for years that a long flight can interrupt your sleep cycle. They were successful and turned it into a dietary supplement.

Now, when your body’s circadian rhythm is thrown all out of whack, you can take melatonin, and about an hour or so later, it’s likely that you’ll start to feel drowsy.

The benefits of Benadryl

Unlike melatonin, Benadryl isn’t a hormone that’s made naturally in the body. Instead, it’s a pharmaceutical drug designed to treat symptoms brought on by various illnesses. As stated above, Benadryl is an antihistamine that can help overcome symptoms like itching, runny noses, watery eyes, and sneezing.

Several different agents can bring on a histamine response within the body. Your immune system makes chemicals called histamines that respond to allergens like dust, pollen, and animal dander.

Benadryl works to reduce your body’s histamine response. Drowsiness along with dizziness and fogginess are actually side effects of this medication. You should never drive after taking Benadryl because of these side effects. If all you need is rest, however, then Benadryl is a standard option.

With that said, it’s still recommended to speak with a medical professional before purchasing and using Benadryl for use as a sleep aid.

Downsides to using melatonin

Although melatonin is not a pharmaceutical drug, it still has a few downsides. For example, it may interact negatively with the use of alcohol, some medications, and cannabis. Additionally, some people experience side effects such as headaches, nightmares, transient depression, and even insomnia.

Potential downsides to using Benadryl

Interestingly, although Benadryl is used to help people who experience allergic reactions it can, itself, be an allergen. If you’re someone who is allergic to Benadryl, you obviously should not use this medication.

You should also ask a doctor or pharmacist if it is safe for you to take Benadryl if you have medical conditions like:

  • Liver or kidney disease
  • Heart disease
  • Low blood pressure
  • Glaucoma
  • A thyroid disorder
  • A bladder obstruction or other urinary problems
  • A colostomy or ileostomy
  • A blockage in the stomach
  • A blockage in the intestines; or
  • If you take potassium

Additionally, you should ask a doctor if taking Benadryl is okay if you are pregnant or nursing.

Woman and Man Yawning
Photo by SHVETS production/Pexels

Get some sleep

Remember that there are other sleep aids available besides over-the-counter medicines and dietary supplements. There’s chamomile tea, valerian root, and there’s all kinds of advice for creating the right environment for sleep. For instance, such as turning off your digital devices at least an hour before going to bed.

However, suppose it’s 2:00 a.m., and you’re just laying there tossing and turning. In that case, both melatonin and Benadryl could be effective in helping you drift off to dreamland. Just remember that you should always speak to a medical professional before using Benadryl.

Editors' Recommendations