Skip to main content

Why BMI is misleading, and what metrics you should look at instead

Body mass index, or BMI as it’s commonly known, is one of the most well-known ways to gauge physical fitness or body composition.

All you need is your height, your weight, and any one of the scads of free internet BMI calculators to get your score and learn where it falls on a predetermined scale:

Related Videos
  • Underweight: BMI score of less than 18.5
  • Normal weight: 18.5-24.9
  • Overweight: 25-29.9
  • Obese: 30 or greater

The BMI test is quick, free, convenient, and fairly useful from a public health standpoint — high BMI scores, for example, are consistently linked with heightened risks for heart disease, diabetes, and other serious health problems. It’s not a bad idea to know your BMI score — as long as you realize it doesn’t even begin to give you the 360-degree picture of your health or fitness. Because for all its plusses, BMI simply doesn’t tell the whole story.

For that, you need a little more time and a little more effort, but you’ll get a much more precise, realistic, and nuanced picture. Here’s more on why the BMI score is misleading — and how you can improve on it.

The problems with BMI

According to Dr. Robert Shmerling, MD, a senior faculty editor with Harvard Medical School, “BMI is not a perfect test. For example, results can be thrown off by pregnancy or high muscle mass, and it may not be a good measure of health for children or the elderly.”

There is another very good reason for this. As Shmerling explains, a BMI score “expresses the relationship between your height and weight as a single number that is not dependent on frame size.”

In other words, the BMI test is missing a lot of important data points. It’s a little like making Thanksgiving dinner with two ingredients.

To take more information into account, you need to dive a little deeper into your body dimensions.

Here’s what to do instead

There are a few different ways to fill in the gaps that exist in the BMI score. Try one or more of these alternative tools to see what works best for you.

Relative fat mass

Like BMI, relative fat mass (RFM) is a relatively simple calculation, but instead of weight, RFM relies on waist circumference. The formula differs slightly between men and women.

  • Men: 64 – (20 x height/waist circumference — both in inches)
  • Women: 76 – (20 x height/waist circumference — both in inches))

Studies have shown that the results achieved through RFM are more accurate and useful than BMI, and more closely resemble results found through more complex clinical tests.

Waist-to-Hip Ratio

Anyone with a measuring tape and a few extra minutes can quickly calculate their waist-to-hip ratio, or WHR. Here’s how to do it:

  • Stand up straight and measure your waist circumference by circling a tape measure around the smallest part of your waist, just above your belly button.
  • Measure your hip circumference using the distance around the widest part of your hips.
  • Divide your waist circumference by your hip circumference.

A healthy WHR is 0.9 or less in men and 0.85 or less for women.

If you’re going to rely on this number moving forward, just be sure you’re consistent in when you measure yourself and where specifically on your body you are taking the measurements.

Both RFM and WHR have been shown to be more effective than BMI in gauging a full picture of body composition and serving as an early warning sign of sorts for the potential health risks that accompany being overweight or obese.

They also are better tools for assessing your personal fitness levels. Fat accumulates in the body in different patterns for different people over time — and also accumulates differently than muscle — so using the unique dimensions of your body naturally provides a more accurate picture.

While BMI can work as a general guidepost, it’s not the best tool for deeper dives into your body composition. Try either of these two to gain a clearer sense of your health and fitness levels.

BlissMark provides information regarding health, wellness, and beauty. The information within this article is not intended to be medical advice. Before starting any diet or exercise routine, consult your physician. If you don’t have a primary care physician, the United States Health & Human Services department has a free online tool that can help you locate a clinic in your area. We are not medical professionals, have not verified or vetted any programs, and in no way intend our content to be anything more than informative and inspiring.

Editors' Recommendations

4 telltale signs you have a weak core
how to tell weak core woman slouching desk

It seems no one can get through even the most casual conversation about fitness without hearing those two magic words: core strength.

It’s an understandable phenomenon. Your core – defined as the muscles around the trunk of your body, including abs, diaphragm, obliques, hips, and glutes — powers many of your everyday activities, from standing to sitting to maintaining your balance. It may not get you noticed on the beach, but your core is critical to helping you stay strong where it matters most.

Read more
Scientists say these 8 foods may reduce the risk of breast cancer
diet breast cancer woman superfoods blender

Breast cancer is the most common form of cancer in America. In fact, the National Cancer Institute estimates there will be 284,200 new cases and almost 44,000 fatalities for 2021 alone.

To help reduce the risk, the American Cancer Society recommends regular screenings and mammograms for women starting at age 45.

Read more
WFH? You might have pandemic posture, and you need to fix it
Woman sitting on couch working on laptop hunched over coffee table

For many of us working from home became the norm during the pandemic, opening up a whole new world of flexibility – yes, you can walk the dog and throw your laundry in during the workday – and freedom from commutes. On the flip side, WFH has also brought on a host of back, shoulder, neck, and other physical pains, something so prevalent, experts have dubbed it “pandemic posture.”

Pandemic posture doesn’t only affect the muscles and joints, but the entire body, and even our mental states. A 2020 survey from Lenovo found that 71% of respondents complained of new or worsening aches and pains since working remotely including back and neck pain, poor posture, headaches, increased eye strain, and even trouble sleeping.

Read more